spot_imgspot_img

Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts

Elected Democrats Are Still Holding Firm On Progressive Tradition

The New Affordability Agenda shows that traditional progressive politics is still about working families, affordability, universal health care, democracy, and dignity, not anti-Israel extremism.

SHARE
Blue and Gold Now Opening Facebook Cover Photo

SARASOTA, Floridaย โ€” On April 29, the Congressional Progressive Caucus announced what it calls the New Affordability Agenda, a package of policy proposals aimed at lowering the cost of everyday life for working Americans. The announcement can be read here:

https://progressives.house.gov/2026/4/progressive-caucus-announces-new-affordability-agenda

The agenda focuses on prescription drugs, groceries, housing, utility bills, gas, childcare, paid vacation, overtime pay, surveillance pricing, corporate price gouging, and Super PACs.

I am thrilled by this agenda and embrace what it includes. This is the kind of progressive domestic policy Democrats should be talking about loudly, clearly, and proudly.

But what is not in the list screams as loudly to me as what is in the list, and I am thrilled by that too.

There is nothing anti-Israel in it.

Nothing pro Hamas.

Nothing about Palestine.

Nothing about Gaza.

Nothing about the Middle East.

Nothing about blaming Israel.

That absence matters.

For many Jewish Democrats and pro-Israel progressives, the word โ€œprogressiveโ€ has become emotionally complicated since October 7. Too often, people who call themselves progressive have used the language of justice, human rights, decolonization, and liberation to excuse Hamas, minimize Jewish suffering, demonize Israel, or turn Zionism into a dirty word.

That is not the progressive tradition I grew up believing in.

When I called myself progressive years ago, I did not mean supporting terrorism, excusing hostage taking, or treating the Jewish state as uniquely illegitimate. I meant civil rights. Voting rights. Labor rights. Womenโ€™s rights. Religious freedom. LGBTQ rights. Affordable health care. Public education. Fair wages. Economic opportunity. Democracy. The idea is that the government should help ordinary people live with dignity.

Imagine that. I just used โ€œtraditionalโ€ and โ€œprogressiveโ€ in the same sentence.

And that is exactly the point.

The Congressional Progressive Caucus just released a domestic economic agenda that looks a lot more like what traditional progressives have always cared about: helping working families, lowering costs, challenging corporate power, improving wages, expanding childcare, addressing housing, and making everyday life more affordable.

That should not be shocking.

But in the current political climate, it feels almost revolutionary.

For those who are worried that Islamic jihadist propaganda has taken over the Democratic Party, this agenda should be comforting. It says something very important by what it does not say. It does not adopt the language of the anti-Israel fringe. It does not turn a domestic affordability platform into a Middle East manifesto. It does not use progressive economics as a Trojan horse for anti Zionism.

The silence is loud.

And we should embrace it.

This does not mean the Democratic Party has no problems. It does. There are voices inside the party and inside progressive spaces that have become far too comfortable with anti-Israel rhetoric, anti Zionist hostility, and narratives that excuse or sanitize Hamas and Islamic jihad.

We know who some of those voices are.

But those voices are not the whole party.

They are not the whole progressive movement.

They are not the whole Democratic caucus.

And this agenda is evidence of that.

It shows that the loudest anti-Israel voices are not necessarily the governing center of the party. They are loud. They are dangerous. They must be challenged. But they have not captured the whole institution.

Hold steady.

Stay in the Democratic Party.

Fight for the party.

Do not abandon the field to the very people trying to push Jews and Zionists out of progressive spaces.

The anti-Israel rhetoric we are hearing now is powerful, damaging, and morally wrong. But political fashions rise and fall. Propaganda waves crest and break. What lasts is organizing, voting, showing up, building coalitions, and refusing to surrender the values we have spent our lives defending.

This agenda is a reminder that the traditional progressive center is still there.

For elected officials, candidates, and newcomers thinking about running for office, this agenda should also be clear.

You do not have to pander to extremism.

You do not have to echo anti-Israel rhetoric.

You do not have to appease people who excuse Hamas, sanitize Islamic jihad, or treat Jewish self-determination as illegitimate.

Stay focused on the real progressive agenda: affordability, health care, housing, childcare, wages, labor rights, democracy, corporate accountability, and helping working families.

That is where the broad center of the Democratic Party still lives.

That is where most voters live.

And if you stay there, if you stand for working people, defend democracy, reject antisemitism, and refuse to make Israel a partisan wedge issue, you can build a long and honorable career.

The elected leadership of the Congressional Progressive Caucus chose to focus on domestic economic policy. They chose affordability. They chose working families. They chose utilities, groceries, gas prices, housing, childcare, prescription drugs, overtime, paid vacation, corporate power, and money in politics.

That is a statement.

It is not the statement the mainstream media seems interested in covering.

And that raises a serious question.

Why has this received so little attention?

It did not break through into the mainstream media conversation. I am a news junkie. This agenda was released on my birthday, April 29, and I still missed it. I was watching and flipping between MSNBC and CNN, and I even tuned in to Fox. I do not remember hearing about it. In fact, it took more than two weeks for it to find its way into my Facebook group, โ€œWe Are Progressive, Liberal, Woke and Pro Israel,โ€ because member John Kranick brought it to our attention.

If the Congressional Progressive Caucus had released a statement attacking Israel, centering Palestinian suffering, or using inflammatory Middle East language, would the media have covered it more aggressively?

Probably.

Conflict gets clicks.

Division gets airtime.

The anti-Israel controversy gets amplified.

But a serious affordability agenda aimed at helping working families? That gets ignored.

That tells us something about the broken media incentive structure. The press often rewards the loudest, most divisive voices while overlooking the boring but important work of policy. The result is that Americans are left with a distorted picture of what progressives actually do, what Democrats actually propose, and who actually controls the agenda.

That distortion matters deeply to Jewish Democrats.

Because many of us are constantly told, by the right and by the anti-Israel left, that there is no place for us in the Democratic Party anymore.

The right tells us: leave the Democrats, they hate Israel.

The anti-Israel left tells us: Leave your Zionism, it has no place in progressive politics.

Both are wrong.

The truth is that pro-Israel Democrats are not politically homeless.

We are needed.

We are still here.

And we need to fight for the Democratic Party from within, not abandon it to the loudest anti-Israel voices.

Support for Israel must not become the property of one political party. That would be dangerous for Israel, dangerous for Jews, and dangerous for America. Israel has been strongest in American politics when Democrats and Republicans both supported its right to exist, defend itself, and thrive as the democratic homeland of the Jewish people.

That bipartisan support did not happen by accident. It was built by generations of Jews and allies who understood that Israelโ€™s security cannot depend on which party controls the White House in any given year.

When Israel becomes a wedge issue, Israel becomes weaker.

When pro-Israel Democrats leave the Democratic Party, anti-Israel Democrats gain more space.

When progressive Zionists are pushed out of progressive spaces, the word โ€œprogressiveโ€ itself becomes easier for extremists to hijack.

That is why this affordability agenda matters beyond the policies themselves.

It reminds us that progressive politics does not have to mean anti-Israel politics.

You can support affordable childcare and support Israel.

You can support lower prescription drug prices and support Israel.

You can support workers, unions, paid vacation, overtime pay, housing affordability, and support Israel.

You can challenge corporate power, oppose Super PACs, fight price gouging, and still believe that Hamas is evil, Islamic jihad is a threat to civilization, and Israel has the right to defend itself.

These are not contradictions.

They are the moral center that many of us have been trying to defend.

And here is something else American progressives should understand: many of the values we are fighting for in America already exist, in one form or another, in Israel.

Israel is not perfect. No country is. I criticize Israeli leadership myself. But Israel is a democratic society with universal health care. It has free compulsory preschool beginning at age 3, reducing the childcare burden for families during years when many American parents are still paying heavily for daycare, while giving children an earlier start in education. It provides dental coverage for children through the national health system. It has paid maternity benefits, strong labor traditions, unions, public education, social welfare structures, religious diversity, LGBTQ visibility, women in public life, Arab citizens in universities, hospitals, courts, politics, and professional life, and a vibrant, argumentative democracy where citizens protest their own government loudly and publicly.

In other words, Israel already contains many of the social democratic values American progressives say they want here.

That matters.

Because the current administration in the United States is shredding decades of progressive progress, rights, protections, public institutions, environmental standards, civil liberties, democratic norms, and social commitments that took generations to build are being attacked, weakened, or dismantled.

America needs more of the humane, pro-family, pro-worker, pro-democracy values that progressives have historically fought for.

And ironically, many of those values are already embedded in Israeli society.

This is where my background in economic sociology and labor studies shapes what I see.

A strong social safety net is not only a moral achievement. It can also be an economic advantage.

Israelโ€™s social safety net did not appear yesterday. It has been part of the countryโ€™s social fabric from the beginning. As Israel grew, matured, absorbed waves of immigrants, built industries, defended itself, and developed a modern economy, that safety net grew with it.

And that safety net helped create the conditions for innovation.

In America, large corporations often have an advantage because they can offer stronger health benefits, retirement plans, and other protections that smaller companies struggle to match. That leaves millions of workers tied to employers for benefits, while many entrepreneurs and small businesses carry a heavy burden just trying to compete for talent. People with ideas often hesitate to leave secure jobs because they cannot afford to lose health coverage or risk their familyโ€™s basic security.

Israel developed differently.

When entrepreneurs do not have to create an entire private health care safety net to attract top employees, they can focus more energy on invention, research, product development, competition, and global markets. When workers and families have access to health care, education, childcare support, and basic social protections outside the employer relationship, people have more room to take risks, join startups, build companies, pursue science, and imagine the future.

Israelโ€™s high-tech success did not happen despite its social democratic foundation. In many ways, it grew alongside it.

Israel has developed far too much technology to list in one article. Medical technology. Agricultural technology. Water technology. Cybersecurity. Defense systems. Energy technology. Communications. Software. Navigation. Emergency response systems. And chances are, if you are reading this right now, you are using or benefiting from technologies that Israeli researchers, engineers, companies, or military partnerships helped develop.

Israel is economically strong not because it rejected progressive social investment, but because it combined national purpose, public investment, education, immigration, military necessity, entrepreneurship, and a social safety net that gave people room to build.

Israel did not build those social systems because American taxpayers are paying for them. That point needs to be said plainly. Yes, Israel receives roughly $3.8 billion a year in U.S. military assistance, support designed to help Israel maintain the military edge it needs in a very dangerous neighborhood. But that is military assistance, much of it tied to purchasing American defense equipment. It is not a blank check for Israelโ€™s health care, preschool, child dental coverage, paid maternity benefits, or social welfare system.

Israel can sustain those programs because it has matured into a thriving, vibrant economy with a powerful high-tech sector, strong domestic innovation, and globally competitive industries. Israel licenses technology to the world, exports advanced defense and cyber systems, develops medical, agricultural, water, energy, and security technologies, and has built one of the most dynamic innovation economies on earth.

That matters because anti-Israel activists often caricature Israel as though it is merely a militarized outpost funded by the United States. That is false. Israel is a modern democratic society, a major innovation economy, and a country that has chosen to invest in public goods while also defending itself against Islamic jihad, Iranian proxies, and enemies that openly seek its destruction.

Israel also protects the holy sites of multiple faiths. Jews, Christians, Muslims, Druze, Bahaโ€™i, and others live, worship, work, study, vote, serve, argue, protest, and build lives inside a complicated but functioning democratic society.

So when anti-Israel activists try to convince American progressives that Israel is the opposite of progressive values, they are not only attacking Israel. They are distorting reality.

A country with universal health care, free preschool beginning at age 3, child dental coverage, paid maternity benefits, democratic elections, independent courts, womenโ€™s rights, LGBTQ visibility, religious diversity, Arab doctors, Arab judges, Arab members of parliament, and mass public protests against its own government is not the enemy of progressive values.

It is a complicated, imperfect, thriving democracy that has already achieved many things American progressives are still trying to win.

That is why progressive Zionists should not be on the defensive.

We should be saying clearly: we support progressive values in America, and we support Israel because Israel, at its best, reflects many of those same values while standing on the front line against Islamic jihad.

For Jewish Democrats, this should be clarifying.

We do not need to surrender the word progressive to people who excuse Hamas. We do not need to surrender the Democratic Party to people who demonize Israel. We do not need to let Islamic jihadist propaganda redefine human rights as hostility to Jews.

We can be progressive, liberal, pro-working family, pro-democracy, pro-human rights, and pro-Israel at the same time.

That is not a compromise position.

That is the position.

The Congressional Progressive Caucus did something important here, whether intentionally or not. By putting forward a serious domestic economic agenda without dragging Israel, Palestine, Gaza, or the Middle East into it, it reminded America that progressive politics still has a domestic moral core.

Affordability matters.

Working families matter.

Universal health care matters.

Democracy matters.

Corporate accountability matters.

And yes, Israel matters too.

But progressive values do not require blaming Israel for everything wrong in the world.

Progressive values do not require giving Hamas a pass.

Progressive values do not require pretending Islamic jihad is โ€œresistance.โ€

Progressive values do not require Jews to apologize for Zionism.

The anti-Israel fringe wants people to believe that being progressive means standing against Israel.

This agenda shows otherwise.

Now the rest of us need to say it out loud.

Progressive does not mean anti-Israel.

Progressive does not mean pro-Hamas.

Progressive does not mean surrendering Jewish safety to political fashion.

Progressive means fighting for human dignity, democracy, fairness, economic justice, civil rights, labor rights, womenโ€™s rights, LGBTQ rights, religious freedom, universal health care, and the right of all peoples, including the Jewish people, to live in freedom and security.

That is the tradition worth reclaiming.

The current administration is trying to roll back decades of American progress. The anti-Israel fringe is trying to hijack the language of progressivism and turn it against Jews. Islamic jihadist propaganda is trying to teach young Americans that Hamas is resistance and Israel is oppression.

All three must be resisted.

We need a Democratic Party that remembers what progressive politics actually means.

We need a progressive movement that fights for working families without surrendering to anti Zionism.

We need Jewish Democrats and pro-Israel allies to stop apologizing for belonging in the room.

And we need the media to recognize that the real story is not only the loud anti-Israel fringe.

The real story is that traditional progressive values are still alive, still necessary, and still compatible with unapologetic support for Israel.

Progressive does not mean anti-Israel.

Progressive does not mean pro-Hamas.

Progressive does not mean surrendering Jewish safety to political fashion.

Progressive means fighting for a better society while defending democracy from those who would destroy it.

That includes defending American democracy.

That includes defending Israel.

That includes defeating Islamic jihad.

And that is the conversation the media should be covering.

Blue and Gold Now Opening Facebook Cover Photo

TheJ Op Ed

Support Us J

Mitch Mallett
Mitch Mallett
Mitch Mallett is president of the Sarasota Manatee Democratic Jewish Caucus and serves on the Florida Democratic Jewish Caucus state board. He writes on Israel, democracy, and political dialogue in progressive spaces, and founded the online community โ€œWe Are Progressive, Liberal, Woke and Pro Israel,โ€ which has more than 5,000 members.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

spot_img

Subscribe

Don't miss another important story, subscribe now to The J's newsletter .

spot_img