JERUSALEM, Israel – The accusations set off a storm in Israel. The reporting it was built on was published two years
ago, and at the time Israel barely reacted.
Culture Minister Miki Zohar accused those behind the reports of treason and demanded they be stripped of their citizenship. Benjamin Netanyahu promised a law allowing the state to revoke the citizenship of Israelis who defame IDF soldiers abroad. Outside the homes of the whistleblowers’ families, demonstrators chanted “Execute these traitors.”
The opposition condemned it too. Gadi Eisenkot called the criticisms morally blind; Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Liberman called it a monstrous blood libel. Yair Golan of the Democrats offered a terse “I condemn.” Rights groups backed the critics. Six weeks before the October 27 election, no politician would defend them.
2024 Passed Quietly
The reporting behind the fallout came out two years ago. An investigation of the Lavender system was published in +972 Magazine and Local Call in April 2024, with a parallel piece in The Guardian, and the Western press followed. Even then, the account was that AI flagged tens of thousands of Gazans as suspects, that checking a recommendation took about twenty seconds, and that commanders set the permissible number of civilian deaths. The IDF replied that the systems only assist analysts, and the State Department told Congress that Israel’s assurances were credible. The current backlash rests on more witnesses, but the accusations are the same.
What the Numbers Show
In October 2024, the Dor Moriah Analytical Center and Geocartography asked 1,005 Israeli adults to place themselves between two statements, “the Jews are the chosen people” and “the Jews are one of many ancient peoples.” 63.7 percent leaned toward the first.
The sample held 443 religious, ultra-Orthodox and traditional Jews and 402 secular ones, and about 640 respondents leaned toward chosenness. Even if every religious and traditional respondent agreed, 197 supporters would remain, and they are secular Jews. Half of secular Israelis hold the belief too.
Three Meanings of Chosenness
Agreeing with the phrase says nothing about what chosenness demands of the chosen, and Haredim, religious Zionists and secular Zionists answer differently. These are ideal types, and every camp has its currents.
●For Haredim, chosenness means an obligation to Torah and the commandments, and redemption does not depend on a Jewish state. The only question is whether Israel helps or hinders Torah study.
●For national-religious Zionists, chosenness confers a right to the land and sovereignty over it. The state is holy but unfinished until people, land and sovereignty coincide, so giving up part of the land is a retreat from its purpose, and outside verdicts demanding exactly that are read as weapons. Within this camp the statist wing works through state
institutions while the hardal wing treats them as an obstacle, and in the fight over the army that difference matters most.
●For secular Zionists, chosenness was translated into moral terms, from Ben-Gurion’s “light unto the nations” to today’s “most moral army in the world” and “only democracy in the Middle East.” Such formulas measure Israel against other states and depend on outside recognition. The pattern is older than Zionism. In Jewish tradition, conduct the nations can see either sanctifies God’s Name or desecrates it, and secular Zionism put the state where the Name had been.
The Moral Stumbling Block
When international institutions and foreign audiences echo these investigations, the accusations hit differently. Criticisms about Masafer Yatta or West Bank outposts are treated by secular Israel as the settlers’ business rather than its own. But accusations about how the IDF chooses targets and how many civilian deaths it accepts in advance strike at the core: the “most moral army in the world” is what secular Israel offers as proof of its chosenness.
Eisenkot, the former chief of staff, called criticism legitimate in a democracy and in the same breath condemned critics for taking what he called a distorted accusation onto an international stage for applause. He could not rule criticism out entirely, because the right to examine oneself belongs to the same claim of chosenness and moral superiority he is defending.
The secular and national-religious versions of chosenness converge on one point. An Israeli who testifies against his country before an applauding foreign audience risks being placed outside the nation. “Blood libel” sets internal critics among the historic persecutors of Jews; Netanyahu turned that exclusion into a bill, and the far right carried it into the language of physical violence.
The Fight Over the IDF and the Golem
The dispute struck the army at a moment when it had already stopped being a shared sanctity. Two versions of chosenness are fighting over it. For secular Israelis, the army supplies proof of their chosenness before the world, a power base alongside the courts and the universities, and a future in which Israel is still the only democracy in the Middle East with the most moral army in the world. Religious Zionists need it to hold the land and extend sovereignty over territory granted by the covenant. Haredim take no part.
Institutions change hands through elections and appointments, which is how that base can be lost. Senior command posts still belong to the secular camp, but religious Zionists are advancing from below through the officer corps.
Both camps are dismantling the army’s sanctity. The left points to looting in southern Lebanon, the treatment of detainees at Sde Teiman and soldiers who stood by during settler attacks; the right defends soldiers against the generals and the military prosecutors. Israelis still trust the army, but not its own inquiries. INSS polling in September 2025 put trust in the IDF at 75 percent and trust in its investigations at 37 percent.
Recent testimonies add an accusation the fight has not seen before: that AI reduced the human in the loop to a formality. The IDF’s defense is that the systems only process data and a human approves every strike, but the witnesses describe seconds spent on review.
In Jewish tradition, the golem moves and acts but lacks daat, the knowledge that discerns. There is nothing in it to judge, and responsibility falls on the maker who set it going and lost control. An army can call itself the most moral in the world only if people in it weigh the cost of a strike and answer for it. Once an AI does the weighing, the army has no moral agent left to answer for the strike.
Three Possible Futures
1.The Besieged Fortress: If secular Israelis go on answering criticism in the language of siege, their version of chosenness will merge with the religious Zionists’, and no one will be left to argue seriously for territorial concessions or equal rights for Arab citizens.
2.The Civic State: A state built on universal norms and equal status for its citizens. Chosenness there is either dropped or kept as a higher standard, and outside criticism becomes a claim to be tested rather than dismissed in advance.
3.The Breakup of the Common Political Space: Arrives when the camps stop recognizing institutions capable of settling the argument between them. Haredim may keep their internal autonomy longer, but they will not escape the consequences.
TheJ.ca receives no government money. Independent journalism depends on readers who believe these stories must be told. Please consider supporting our efforts.


