WINNIPEG, Canada – Before Manitoba congratulates itself on a historic advance in human rights, it owes its Jewish, Israeli and Zionist residents an answer: Will defending Jewish self-determination remain an entirely legitimate position in our public institutions?
That question deserves more than a reassuring slogan.
The National Council of Canadian Muslims says Manitoba has become the first province to recognize anti-Palestinian racism across government. Its announcement presents the recognition as part of a broader record of Palestinian advocacy and links confronting this racism to combating Islamophobia.
The photograph makes that question immediate.

A post published jointly under the CPAM and Ramsey Zeid Instagram accounts shows Kinew smiling beside Zeid, president of the Canadian Palestinian Association of Manitoba, at the legislature. Its caption celebrates the recognition and thanks Kinew and Kennedy. The accompanying Islamic Heritage Month event program is dated October 14, 2026.
At the very gathering associated with this anti-racism milestone, the premier posed with a man whose public rhetoric has already prompted serious, documented objections from Jewish advocates.
B’nai Brith Canada identifies Zeid as a member of the museum’s advisory network and attributes to him the statement that Zionism is “a disease that must be destroyed.”
For Jews who understand Zionism as their right to national self-determination, the implications of that language are plain. Their attachment to a Jewish homeland is presented as a sickness requiring eradication.
The record extends further. An August 5 Jerusalem Post report, describing B’nai Brith’s review of social media material, reported that Zeid shared an Instagram reel in October 2024 justifying what Palestinians did on October 7. It also documented organ-theft accusations circulated by Zeid and CPAM, which the review treated as antisemitic blood libels.
TheJ.ca’s January 2025 coverage also showed a screenshot attributed to Zeid, featuring an Israeli flag beside images of ticks beneath a heading describing parasites.
Disgusting imagery attached to the Jewish state should trouble any premier claiming to bring communities together.
This controversy was public long before the latest photograph. In May 2025, the Winnipeg Free Press reported that Coun. Sherri Rollins accused Zeid of sharing threatening anti-Zionist material and sought the withdrawal of a business award. Zeid denied her accusations, describing them as false and misleading, and said he opposed hate and intolerance.
His denial belongs on the record. So do the specific statements and images that Jewish organizations have challenged.
A photograph does not establish that Kinew endorses every statement Zeid has made. It does require the premier to explain whether he rejects that rhetoric and what standards govern the access and recognition his government extends.
Is this how Manitoba intends to reassure its Jewish, Israeli and Zionist citizens?
They are asked to trust an expanding anti-racism agenda while their premier poses beside a figure whom B’nai Brith publicly associates with language demanding the destruction of Zionism.
The contradiction demands an answer.
The contradiction is sharper because Manitoba has already adopted a framework for identifying precisely these forms of hatred.
On October 27, 2022, the province adopted the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s working definition of antisemitism under Premier Heather Stefanson. The government said it would help policymakers and community leaders identify and combat contemporary antisemitism.
Kinew subsequently made that commitment his own. When asked in the legislature on June 3, 2024 whether he stood by IHRA, he answered, “Yes, I do.” He went on to endorse the importance of its explanatory examples and public office holders’ responsibility to confront antisemitism.
That record makes the photograph a test of his own stated principles.
IHRA’s examples address denying Jewish self-determination, using classic antisemitic imagery to characterize Israel or Israelis, comparing contemporary Israeli policy to Nazism, and ideologically justifying harm to Jews. The framework requires context and protects ordinary criticism of Israel. Canada’s explanatory handbook specifically discusses organ-theft accusations as a modern adaptation of blood libel.

The material attributed to Zeid engages those examples directly. The organ-theft allegations recycle the blood-libel pattern. Describing Zionism as a disease requiring destruction attacks Jewish national self-determination. The Nazi comparisons reproduced in TheJ.ca’s earlier coverage fall within another expressly identified example. Justification of October 7 must be assessed against the example concerning ideologically motivated harm to Jews.
Taken together, this is a substantial, documented case of rhetoric that crosses the IHRA line into antisemitism.
IHRA is non-legally binding; its adoption does not make a photograph or a statement a criminal offence. The question is political credibility: will Kinew apply the standard he publicly endorsed when it becomes uncomfortable?
A premier who praises IHRA’s examples should be prepared to address those examples when they arise in the public record of someone beside him at the legislature.
Otherwise, adoption becomes ceremonial. Jewish residents receive a definition on paper while the conduct it helps identify is met with smiles and silence.
But a government announcement cannot settle the boundaries of racism by applause. Those boundaries determine whose speech is protected, whose identity attracts suspicion, and whose account of history can trigger a complaint.
Palestinians deserve protection from threats, discrimination, and dehumanization. That principle is clear. The controversy begins when a framework extends protection from people to political narratives.
The Arab Canadian Lawyers Association’s influential 2022 description includes conduct directed at Palestinians “or their narratives.” It identifies denying the Nakba and failing to acknowledge Palestinian indigeneity among its manifestations. Elsewhere, its explanatory text describes Zionism as serving to maintain Jewish supremacy.
That is a political interpretation with enormous implications for Jews who understand Zionism as their people’s right to national self-determination in their ancestral homeland.
Manitoba must explain whether it has adopted this description, another definition or merely a statement of recognition. Until the government publishes the operative wording and its intended application, nobody should pretend the consequences have been settled.
The ACLA report itself says its framework must not impede good-faith discussion and does not excuse antisemitic expression. Those qualifications matter. If Manitoba draws on this framework, it must make those safeguards explicit and enforceable.
Otherwise, who decides whether a Jewish student’s defence of Israel constitutes legitimate disagreement or the erasure of a Palestinian narrative?
Who protects an Israeli teacher who challenges a classroom account of 1948? Who ensures a civil servant can reject the description of Israel as a colonial project without being treated as professionally suspect?
These are foreseeable risks, not findings that Manitoba has already imposed such penalties. Recognition alone does not demonstrate that new sanctions exist. The danger lies in what institutions may subsequently build around it.
A loosely drafted training module can become a workplace expectation. A workplace expectation can become grounds for a complaint. People may learn to remain silent long before any formal punishment occurs.
The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs has already warned that expansive applications of the concept could suppress dissent, undermine Israeli identity and obstruct complaints about antisemitism. The government should respond to those warnings in writing.
NCCM’s account of Minister Nellie Kennedy’s remarks also demands scrutiny. Understanding the intersection of anti-Muslim prejudice and hostility toward Palestinians is reasonable. Making agreement on Palestine a test of whether someone opposes Islamophobia would be an intolerable overreach.
A Manitoban can defend Muslim neighbours, condemn anti-Muslim hatred and remain an unapologetic Zionist. Government has no business making those commitments seem incompatible.
Then comes the celebration of Isha Khan.

The October 14 event program lists the Canadian Museum for Human Rights CEO as the Northern Lights Awards recipient for Human Rights Advocacy. NCCM’s congratulatory statement specifically highlights the Nakba exhibit she launched.
The program does not identify the exhibit as the award’s formal basis. NCCM nevertheless chose to foreground it as part of celebrating her leadership.
For those concerned about the museum’s judgment, that association deepens the problem.
The museum presents Palestine Uprooted: Nakba Past and Present as an exploration of Palestinian displacement, connecting 1948 with present experiences through the concept of an ongoing Nakba. Its website says the exhibit rests on rigorous research and curation.
Those claims invite scrutiny. A national museum should welcome demands for historical context with the same confidence it brings to defending its curatorial choices.
Former trustee Mark L. Berlin resigned over the exhibit. In his published account, he alleged inadequate transparency, insufficient historical context, and a failure to meaningfully involve mainstream Jewish representatives in its development.
The museum says it listened to competing views and that Palestinian Canadian experiences belong in its galleries.
That does not resolve Berlin’s objections. Palestinian testimony and the adequacy of the museum’s historical framing are separate questions.
Zeid’s advisory role makes the museum’s judgment an additional, concrete issue.
His involvement is independently reported. The Art Newspaper’s June 26 preview identified him as part of the Palestinian community advisory network the museum consulted. B’nai Brith’s concerns therefore concern someone with access to the exhibit’s development process, not merely an outside supporter.
The museum owes the public a record of how it assessed that access. What vetting took place? Were the publicly circulated posts reviewed? Who decided whether his rhetoric met a human rights institution’s standards? What recommendations did he make, and how were they evaluated?
An adviser need not be politically neutral. But a museum should distinguish lived experience and legitimate advocacy from a record of demonizing the people whose history its exhibit also interprets.
Palestinian family testimony can be preserved and presented with dignity while advisers’ public rhetoric is subjected to rigorous scrutiny. The museum must explain how it maintained that distinction.
Consultation alone does not establish that Zeid wrote or controlled the exhibit. That is why the museum should disclose the scope of his contribution and the safeguards applied.
The governance controversy deepened in August, when the Winnipeg Free Press reported that Zeid argued trustees should leave exhibition decisions to museum professionals. Khan defended the exhibit’s place within the museum’s mandate, while board chair Benjie Nycum emphasized the board’s governance role and its collective decisions.
Those positions do not answer the vetting questions. Curatorial independence carries responsibilities for accuracy, professional judgment, and source scrutiny. Governance must ensure it meets those responsibilities.
For Khan, an award for human rights advocacy cannot close that discussion. Her leadership should be judged partly by whether the institution examined its advisers’ records and answered affected communities with evidence.
The public deserves to know how the exhibit addresses Jewish self-determination, the decisions that produced the 1948 war and the security context of subsequent conflicts. A visitor should be able to encounter Palestinian loss without being steered toward the conclusion that Jewish sovereignty itself is the underlying human rights violation.
A museum’s obligation to examine suffering does not relieve it of the obligation to explain history.
That obligation becomes especially serious when students arrive under the authority of a school visit. Young people need the tools to examine evidence and competing interpretations. An institution fails them when moral certainty replaces historical inquiry.
And an award cannot answer a trustee’s objections. Applause cannot supply missing context. Celebrating leadership does not settle whether that leadership served every community fairly.
Premier Wab Kinew’s government should publish the exact wording of its recognition, identify every intended administrative consequence, and disclose who was consulted.
It should guarantee that support for Israel’s existence, advocacy for Jewish self-determination, evidence-based criticism of Palestinian leadership and good-faith challenges to historical claims will remain legitimate.
Any implementation should include a fair complaints process, clear evidentiary standards and protection against treating Jewish or Israeli identity as proof of political wrongdoing.
Kinew should also state plainly whether describing Zionism as a disease to be destroyed is compatible with his government’s anti-racism commitments. Jewish residents deserve a direct answer, without a diversion into someone else’s misconduct.
The museum’s board should answer the substantive objections to its exhibit separately. Those responsibilities survive every congratulatory announcement.
Jewish Manitobans should not have to bargain away their history to participate in public life. Israelis should not have to apologize for their national identity. Zionists should not have to accept an indictment of Jewish sovereignty to establish their anti-racist credentials.
Manitoba can confront prejudice against Palestinians while protecting those freedoms. It must demonstrate that it intends to do so.
Until then, the victory lap is premature, and the questions are urgent.
TheJ.ca receives no government money. Independent journalism depends on readers who believe these stories must be told. Please consider supporting our efforts.



Excellent analysis, Ron. The CMHR has much to answer for. I can’t believe this has happened in spite of the vast criticism/condemnation of its Nakba exhibit.