spot_imgspot_img

Top 5 This Week

spot_img

Related Posts

Foreign Influence Campaigns Could Exploit Israel’s Deepening Political Divisions, New Survey Warns

A survey of 1,003 Israeli adults reveals how political, religious and social divisions shape perceptions of contentious national debates, potentially creating opportunities for foreign actors to amplify distrust and polarization.

SHARE

TEL AVIV, Israel – A foreign government trying to influence Israeli politics does not need to invent a controversy. It can take an argument Israelis are already having, amplify its sharpest claims, and encourage people to view their political opponents with greater suspicion.

That is the vulnerability exposed by a new survey of how Israelis perceive foreign information influence. The findings do not show that outsiders created Israel’s political divisions. They reveal something more unsettling: arguments about war, government accountability and international pressure are already so closely associated with particular political camps that an outside actor may find ready-made opportunities to exploit them.

Published on October 24 by Dor Moriah, the study was conducted with the Geocartography Knowledge Group among 1,003 adult internet users in Israel. It asked respondents which arguments they hear in public debate and which groups they associate with those arguments.

The distinction matters. The research measures perceptions, not verified foreign operations or changes in voting behavior. It cannot establish that a particular government manufactured a narrative simply because similar claims appear in international messaging.

Asked which arguments were most prominent in Israeli debate, 32.7% identified the allegation that the government’s military and foreign policy decisions primarily serve to keep it in power. Another 29.1% selected the claim that Western countries judge Israel by standards they do not apply to other nations at war.

These arguments differ sharply, but both touch on questions Israelis have every reason to debate. Citizens can challenge their government’s motives without serving foreign interests. They can also question international double standards without dismissing legitimate scrutiny of Israeli conduct.

The survey becomes particularly revealing when it shows how those arguments are distributed across Israel’s social and political landscape.

Among secular respondents, 41.9% identified the allegation about government decisions serving political survival as prominent. That fell to 27.3% among traditional respondents and 24.2% among religious and Haredi respondents.

The figures do not indicate how many people agree with the allegation. They show which arguments respondents recognize as prominent. That perception also varies considerably between communities.

The divide is also visible in attitudes toward Western criticism. Among Jewish respondents, 32.3% identified the double-standards argument as prominent, compared with 11.3% of Arab respondents. Arab participants were somewhat more likely to identify claims about excessive civilian harm in Gaza.

The survey then asked respondents to identify the groups most associated with particular claims.

Among the 203 participants who selected the argument that Israeli operations in Gaza cause excessive civilian harm and should be significantly curtailed, 81.3% associated that position with the political left and 56.2% with Arab citizens of Israel.

Those are not measures of what left-wing Israelis or Arab citizens actually believe. They describe how a smaller group of respondents assigns political identities to an argument.

The same pattern appears in perceptions of government accountability. Among 328 respondents who identified the claim that military and diplomatic decisions serve political survival, 69.8% associated it with the left, 39.9% with the center, and 32.3% with secular Israelis.

Political associations shift when the subject turns to Western double standards. Among the 292 respondents who selected that argument, 53.8% associated it with the right, 32.2% with the center and 31.8% with religious Israelis.

A claim can therefore acquire a political identity before anyone examines its evidence. People may recognize an argument as belonging to the left or right and respond to its supporters’ presumed motives rather than its substance.

That creates an opening for manipulation. An outside campaign can selectively circulate genuine statements, strip away context or exaggerate differences between communities. It need not persuade Israelis to adopt unfamiliar views. Reinforcing existing distrust may be enough to advance its aims.

But the survey cannot tell us whether such campaigns have actually succeeded. Its strongest evidence concerns what respondents fear.

Among 774 participants who identified at least one foreign country or bloc as influential, 78.3% believed international information campaigns deepen social divisions and hostility to a great or very great extent. Another 71.1% believed those campaigns substantially help particular political forces gain power.

Both figures apply to that 774-person subgroup, not the full sample. They describe perceived consequences, not independently measured effects.

Still, the concern matters politically. A society that suspects outside forces of amplifying its internal disputes faces a difficult choice. It must defend itself against manipulation without treating ordinary political disagreement as evidence of foreign allegiance.

That distinction is especially important during war. Questions about civilian casualties, military strategy, and government accountability cannot be dismissed merely because hostile actors might repeat them. Nor should allegations be accepted without evidence because they fit the worldview of a particular political camp.

The same principle applies to claims that Israel faces unfair international treatment. Such claims deserve examination on their merits. The existence of genuine double standards would not invalidate every criticism of Israel, just as legitimate criticism would not make every international judgment consistent or fair.

Dor Moriah’s findings suggest that the challenge reaches beyond identifying hostile sources. It concerns the habits of public debate itself: whether citizens can distinguish evidence from political labeling, criticism from disinformation, and disagreement from disloyalty.

No information policy can eliminate Israel’s real political differences, nor should it try. Those differences concern decisions with profound consequences for the country’s security and future. Democratic debate is how citizens hold leaders accountable and contest those decisions.

Foreign actors may attempt to exploit that debate. Israel’s answer cannot be to make it impossible.

The stronger defense is a public willing to question suspicious messaging without surrendering its right to argue. Israel’s divisions did not begin with foreign information campaigns, and they will not disappear when those campaigns end. What matters is whether Israelis can keep those disagreements from becoming a permanent inability to trust one another.

TheJ.ca receives no government money. Independent journalism depends on readers who believe these stories must be told. Please consider supporting our efforts.

Rachel Avraham
Rachel Avraham
Rachel Avraham is the CEO of the Dona Gracia Center for Diplomacy and an Israel-based journalist.  She is the author of 'Women and Jihad: Debating Palestinian Female Suicide Bombings in the American, Israeli and Arab media.'

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

spot_img

Subscribe

Don't miss another important story, subscribe now to The J's newsletter .

spot_img